American Vintage

★ ★★ ★ ★ ★
HQ:Signes, France
|
Production:Euro-Mediterranean (81.9%)
|
Product Focus:Apparel
|
Style:Classic, Minimalist
|
Price:€€

American Vintage scores 1.5 Stars in its first
RateTheLabel — Sustainable Brand Scoring.

American Vintage was founded in 2005 by Michaël Azoulay in Signes, near Marseille, France. The brand produces 81.9% of its clothing in the Euro-Mediterranean region, specialising in knitwear, t-shirts, and denim with a timeless, essentials-focused design philosophy. Holds five material certifications (GOTS, OCS, RWS, GRS, RCS) verified through Ecocert, though only 18% of cotton is organic. Offers repair services via Tilli partnership.

Dimension Scores

The rating, broken down:

Greenwashing Safe
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
Holds five material certifications verified through Ecocert but applies them to a minority of production. Only 18% of cotton is organic while 64% remains conventional. No sustainability report, no Code of Conduct, no factory list published.
Brand Perception
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
Care guide and repair service via Tilli show longevity investment. However, Good On You rates the brand Very Poor and Trustpilot shows 1.4/5 with 408 reviews, primarily citing customer service and returns issues.
Environment
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
Regional production (81.9% Euro-Mediterranean) and certified materials are genuine strengths. Water-reuse factory for 50%+ of denim production. Mineral dyeing on select lines. However, no deforestation policy, no packaging info, and conventional cotton dominates.
Labor
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
Euro-Mediterranean production since 2005 with long-term regional supplier relationships. No Code of Conduct, no factory names, no supply chain labour certifications. Medium risk tier requires formal documentation not provided.
Circularity
★ ★★ ★ ★ ★
Timeless basics positioning with formal repair service via Tilli partnership. Fabric reuse collaborations with Summer Rambo and About a Worker. No take-back programme, no resale platform, no mono-material design.
Climate
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
No public climate data available. No carbon disclosure, no SBTi registration, no net-zero targets, no offset programme.
Innovation
★ ★ ★★ ★ ★
Mineral dyeing programme on VEGIFLOWER and DEVON lines. Water-reuse factory for denim. Named innovation partnerships with Tilli, Summer Rambo, and About a Worker. No bio-based material innovation.
Bonus: UX
★ ★ ★ ★★ ★
Well-designed e-commerce with international retail presence. Payment options and store accessibility are strong. Customer service is the weakest point with very poor Trustpilot ratings.
Final Verdict

American Vintage holds genuine material certifications but applies them inconsistently. The gap between certification capability and actual sustainable practice — particularly the dominance of conventional cotton and absence of transparency documentation — limits the rating. A brand with infrastructure to score much higher once reporting and transparency catch up.

Assessment Timeline
Rated under RTL v1.4
2026-04-07
Initial assessment · v1.4
NEXT REVIEW · EXPECTED
Scheduled reassessment
Similar Brands

Also rated in this category.

Armedangels
Armedangels
★★★★★4.0 / 5
Cologne, Germany · Casual, Minimalist
H
Hugo Boss
★★★★★★3.5 / 5
Metzingen, Germany · Classic Tailored
ASKET
ASKET
★★★★★★3.5 / 5
Stockholm, Sweden · Scandi Minimalist
Methodologyv1.4
This rating1.5 / 5
Last assessed2026-04-07
See our rating approach →